Attentional bias is a cognitive bias in interpreting one’s environment. It is something that everyone experiences — a natural consequence of human psychology. What causes one person to react in a certain way to a stimulus may not cause another person to react similarly. We are all unique individuals, so how we interpret our surroundings is also unique, allowing for personal biases and delusions.
It is a phenomenon where the human brain tends to over-value and over-weight certain pieces of information in the decision-making process. Understanding attentional bias is significant because it can be responsible for all sorts of behavioral biases and systematic and non-systematic errors in understanding. Let’s dive deeper into it in this article.
What Is Attentional Bias?
Attentional bias is a term used in psychology to describe the tendency of our attention to gravitate toward certain stimuli over others. Attentional biases are often considered a form of implicit association, reflecting automatic tendencies outside our conscious control.
It has been shown to play an essential role in various aspects of human psychology and behavior. Attentional biases can be positive and negative, with positive biases being preferential attention towards a stimulus and negative biases being the avoidance of stimuli.
To understand how attentional bias works, it is essential to understand what attention is. Attention is an umbrella term that describes various cognitive processes to select information for further processing.
These processes include selective attention (the ability to focus on one stimulus while ignoring others), sustained attention (the ability to maintain focus on an object over time), vigilance (the ability to remain alert or ready for action), and orienting (the ability to quickly shift one’s attention from one object or location to another).
Attentional biases can occur at any stage in this process, from the initial perception of an object or stimulus to the decision of whether or not it should be attended to further. Most attentional biases are thought to be developed early in life and are relatively stable over time. However, research also suggests that some biases may be malleable or even reversible through repeated exposure to novel stimuli or other forms of cognitive training.
How Does Attentional Bias Work?
For attentional biases to occur:
1) There needs to be an emotional response
2) Attention needs to shift toward that stimulus or away from another stimulus
3) The emotional response needs to influence behavior (e.g., avoidance of threat)
Why does this happen? The answer lies in how our brains work. The brain is an organ that consumes an enormous amount of energy, so it has developed several mechanisms to conserve energy. One of these mechanisms involves paying attention to only what is essential at any given time; this allows us to ignore everything else so we don’t waste precious energy processing information that isn’t relevant at the moment.
Example of Attentional Bias
The most common example of an attentional bias is the Stroop effect, which occurs when we automatically name the color ink used in a word rather than its meaning (for instance, naming “blue” instead of “red” when presented with the word “red” written in blue). The Stroop effect illustrates how our attention can be drawn away from a task at hand (reading) by an unrelated stimulus (the word itself).
Further, researchers investigated whether the Stroop effect can be modulated by attentional bias for threat in a study done with anxious patients. Spider phobics and non-phobic controls were tested on the Stroop task while presenting either phobia-relevant or neutral stimuli. The results showed that both groups exhibited a significant Stroop effect (i.e., slower responses to incongruent trials). Still, the magnitude of the effect was significantly higher in spider phobics than in controls.
Moreover, this difference was present only when faced with anxiety-provoking stimuli (i.e., spiders) and not in response to neutral stimuli. These findings suggest that attentional bias for threat may explain why anxious people experience more interference from threatening information than others who do not suffer from anxiety disorders.
Key Sub-components of Attentional Bias
Sub-components of attentional bias can be divided into two categories:
The initial orienting stage is the first step in attentional bias. It involves directing our attention to a particular stimulus or event that has caught our interest. On a basic level, this could be as simple as noticing a butterfly flying by and following it with your eyes.
However, it also applies to more complex situations, such as deciding which house to buy based on which one has the best curb appeal. Either way, this is the first step in what we think of as attentional bias because it is essentially an automatic response that we cannot control (although there are ways to train yourself to be more aware of what you notice).
Attentional bias occurs on an unconscious level, but it can be measured by examining reaction times in tasks that require participants to respond to a target stimulus while ignoring other stimuli.
The results of these experiments show that people are faster at detecting targets when they are preceded by stimuli they have previously been exposed to. This demonstrates that people are quicker at detecting things they have been exposed to, even if they do not consciously notice them.
Maintenance Stages of Information Processing
The maintenance stages of information processing occur after initial orienting but before we decide about the stimulus or event at hand. These include factors like working memory and selective attention. In simple terms, it includes further analysis of information about the attended stimuli and decision-making about how best to respond.
For example, when shopping for houses, you might consider several options before deciding which one to buy (selective attention). Still, once you’ve made that decision, you will determine the essential features.
Why Does Attentional Bias Happen?
There are several reasons why attentional bias happens. One reason is that people naturally tend to pay more attention to positive or negative things. For example, if someone is looking at a picture of a face, they will pay more attention to the eyes than any other part because we use our eyes for emotional cues when interacting with others.
In another example, if someone watched two people talking and one person started crying during the conversation, they would automatically pay more attention to that person because crying is usually associated with sadness or stress.
Another reason why attentional bias occurs is due to past experiences and associations with certain situations or stimuli. Suppose someone has had bad experiences with something like spiders in the past. In that case, they might have an automatic adverse reaction when they see one again, even though they don’t know anything about them anymore, because it triggers negative memories from the past, which can cause this.
Attentional biases are often used to explain why people have certain mental disorders. For example, if someone has an anxiety disorder, their attention may be drawn toward threatening stimuli more quickly than others. This can lead them to experience fear when they see something that isn’t threatening.
This can also explain why some people have difficulty controlling their emotions even when there isn’t anything, in particular, causing them discomfort. For example, many people with depression feel sad or anxious even though they aren’t aware of any specific reason for their mood change. This could be because they have an attentional bias toward negative things, which results in them focusing on negative thoughts and feelings even when nothing else is going wrong in their lives.
Related Read: What is Actor-observer Bias?
What Is the Impact of Attentional Bias?
Attentional bias is one of the most studied phenomena in clinical psychology. It involves enhanced or reduced attention toward emotional stimuli (positive or negative) in healthy individuals and patients with emotional disorders, such as depression and anxiety.
It has been found to play an important role in depression and anxiety. For example, depressed individuals often exhibit attentional biases toward sad-looking faces. In addition, they also have difficulty disengaging from threatening stimuli. These findings suggest that hypervigilance toward negative emotional stimuli may contribute to maintaining depressive symptoms, whereas difficulty disengaging from such stimuli may lead to rumination about negative experiences.
How to Overcome Attentional Bias?
Attentional bias can be one of the leading causes of stress and anxiety. When you have an attentional bias for negative things, you become more aware of the bad things in your life, which causes stress and anxiety.
An example is when someone, who has a fear of public speaking, attends a significant event with many people around them. They may find themselves paying more attention to the people around them than they usually would, which makes them feel uncomfortable and anxious.
Being said that, it’s important to note that an attentional bias can be either positive or negative. A positive attentional bias can help you focus on success more than failure. For example, if you’re learning how to golf and hit balls into the woods every time you try, you might want to focus on hitting the ball into the fairway instead of hitting it into the trees again.
However, negative attentional biases can also cause problems when managing stress levels since they cause us to pay more attention to negative things in our lives than positive ones. Some studies have shown that people with depression have a negative attentional bias toward negatively valenced stimuli (such as sad faces).
There are many ways to overcome attentional bias. Here are a few techniques that are supported by research.
- Use the “bias blind spot”: The bias blind spot is the tendency for people to believe they are less biased than others. When people find out they have a bias, they are often surprised and motivated to correct it. This is because they believe they are less biased than average, not because there is anything wrong with them.
- Set goals for overcoming bias as it can help us focus on what we want to achieve, increasing our motivation. Making concrete plans about reducing your biases can effectively overcome them (e.g., “I will only use gender-neutral job descriptions when hiring new employees”).
- Recognize situations where you might be biased: It can be challenging to recognize when we are acting on an assumption or belief that could lead us astray from reality; therefore, it is important to recognize situations where our biases might come into play (e.g., when making decisions about hiring or promotions).
- Practice mindfulness meditation, as it involves focusing your attention on one thought or sensation at a time without judgment or reaction. This type of meditation trains your mind to focus more efficiently and consistently, which can help reduce attentional bias.
Attentional bias is simply what it sounds like: a bias that occurs in focusing our attention (i.e., little attention). It’s called a “bias” because this process isn’t perfect and can be led astray as our brains focus on some aspects of a stimulus more than others.
To summarize, it stems from how our attention is drawn towards a particular and generally occurs unconsciously, influencing how we think and make decisions. However, there are ways to mitigate this problem. By understanding what causes cognitive biases and changing how we gather information, we can work towards a more accurate assessment of the world around us.
- Lichtenstein-Vidne, L., Okon-Singer, H., Cohen, N., Todder, D., Aue, T., Nemets, B., & Henik, A. (2017). Attentional bias in clinical depression and anxiety: The impact of emotional and non-emotional distracting information. Biological Psychology, 122, 4–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2016.07.012
- Begh, R., Munafò, M. R., Shiffman, S., Ferguson, S. G., Nichols, L., Mohammed, M. A., Holder, R. L., Sutton, S., & Aveyard, P. (2013). Attentional bias retraining in cigarette smokers attempting Smoking Cessation (arts): Study protocol for a double blind randomised controlled trial. BMC Public Health, 13(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-13-1176
- Troller-Renfree, S., McLaughlin, K. A., Sheridan, M. A., Nelson, C. A., Zeanah, C. H., & Fox, N. A. (2017). The beneficial effects of a positive attention bias amongst children with a history of psychosocial deprivation. Biological Psychology, 122, 110–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2016.04.008
- Fox, E., Russo, R., & Dutton, K. (2002). Attentional bias for threat: Evidence for delayed disengagement from emotional faces. Cognition & Emotion, 16(3), 355–379. https://doi.org/10.1080/02699930143000527
- Drobes, D. J., Oliver, J. A., Correa, J. B., & Evans, D. E. (2019). Attentional bias and smoking. Neuroscience of Nicotine, 145–150. https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-813035-3.00018-6